Menu | Nellies Sweet Shoppe

Ice Cream

Birthday Cake

Vanilla ice cream with pieces of chocolate cake, a chocolate icing swirl and bright multi-colored candy sprinkles

Kids Cone

Single Cake Cone

$2.25

Double Cake Cone

$3.25

Single Sugar Cone

$2.25

Double Sugar Cone

$3.25

Waffle Bowl

$3.50

Waffle Bowl 2 Scoop

$4.50

Single Cup

$2.25

Double Cup

$3.25

Black Walnut

Combines the special taste of black walnuts with a creamy, rich ice cream. In a nutshell, it's great!

Kids Cone

Single Cake Cone

$2.25

Double Cake Cone

$3.25

Single Sugar Cone

$2.25

Double Sugar Cone

$3.25

Waffle Bowl

$3.50

Waffle Bowl 2 Scoop

$4.50

Single Cup

$2.25

Double Cup

$3.25

Chocolate Chip

A creamy vanilla ice cream with tasty, semi-sweet chocolate chips. It's a chip off the old chocolate block.

Kids Cone

Single Cake Cone

$2.25

Double Cake Cone

$3.25

Single Sugar Cone

$2.25

Double Sugar Cone

$3.25

Waffle Bowl

$3.50

Waffle Bowl 2 Scoop

$4.50

Single Cup

$2.25

Double Cup

$3.25

Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough

A rich, creamy ice cream with chunks of chocolate chip cookie dough and chips of dark chocolate.

Kids Cone

Single Cake Cone

$2.25

Double Cake Cone

$3.25

Single Sugar Cone

$2.25

Double Sugar Cone

$3.25

Waffle Bowl

$3.50

Waffle Bowl 2 Scoop

$4.50

Single Cup

$2.25

Double Cup

$3.25

Cookies and Cream

A creamy vanilla ice cream with tasty chunks of chocolate crème cookies. We were first to create this innovative flavor.

Kids Cone

Single Cake Cone

$2.25

Double Cake Cone

$3.25

Single Sugar Cone

$2.25

Double Sugar Cone

$3.25

Waffle Bowl

$3.50

Waffle Bowl 2 Scoop

$4.50

Single Cup

$2.25

Double Cup

$3.25

Cotton Candy

A delicious cotton candy flavored ice cream in shades of pink and blue.

Kids Cone

Single Cake Cone

$2.25

Double Cake Cone

$3.25

Single Sugar Cone

$2.25

Double Sugar Cone

$3.25

Waffle Bowl

$3.50

Waffle Bowl 2 Scoop

$4.50

Single Cup

$2.25

Double Cup

$3.25

Dutch Chocolate

A rich, creamy chocolate ice cream made with the finest imported chocolate. A royal treat, indeed!

Kids Cone

Single Cake Cone

$2.25

Double Cake Cone

$3.25

Single Sugar Cone

$2.25

Double Sugar Cone

$3.25

Waffle Bowl

$3.50

Waffle Bowl 2 Scoop

$4.50

Single Cup

$2.25

Double Cup

$3.25

Homestyle Strawberry

Smooth, creamy strawberry ice cream made with succulent strawberries. It's berry delicious!

Kids Cone

Single Cake Cone

$2.25

Double Cake Cone

$3.25

Single Sugar Cone

$2.25

Double Sugar Cone

$3.25

Waffle Bowl

$3.50

Waffle Bowl 2 Scoop

$4.50

Single Cup

$2.25

Double Cup

$3.25

Mint Chocolate Chip

A refreshing, creamy mint ice cream sprinkled with delicious semi-sweet chocolate chips.

Kids Cone

Single Cake Cone

$2.25

Double Cake Cone

$3.25

Single Sugar Cone

$2.25

Double Sugar Cone

$3.25

Waffle Bowl

$3.50

Waffle Bowl 2 Scoop

$4.50

Single Cup

$2.25

Double Cup

$3.25

Mocha Almond

Mocha Almond Fudge is a coffee ice cream accented with chopped roasted almonds and a rich chocolate sundae sauce.

Kids Cone

Single Cake Cone

$2.25

Double Cake Cone

$3.25

Single Sugar Cone

$2.25

Double Sugar Cone

$3.25

Waffle Bowl

$3.50

Waffle Bowl 2 Scoop

$4.50

Single Cup

$2.25

Double Cup

$3.25

Pecan Pralines and Cream

A combination of praline sauce swirled into a creamy vanilla ice cream sprinkled with praline-coated pecans.

Kids Cone

Single Cake Cone

$2.25

Double Cake Cone

$3.25

Single Sugar Cone

$2.25

Double Sugar Cone

$3.25

Waffle Bowl

$3.50

Waffle Bowl 2 Scoop

$4.50

Single Cup

$2.25

Double Cup

$3.25

Pistachio Almond

Pistachio ice cream accented with pieces of crunchy, chopped roasted almonds.

Kids Cone

Single Cake Cone

$2.25

Double Cake Cone

$3.25

Single Sugar Cone

$2.25

Double Sugar Cone

$3.25

Waffle Bowl

$3.50

Waffle Bowl 2 Scoop

$4.50

Single Cup

$2.25

Double Cup

$3.25

Rainbow Sherbet

Combines three refreshing sherbet flavors, strawberry, orange, and lime that are naturally low in fat.

Kids Cone

Single Cake Cone

$2.25

Double Cake Cone

$3.25

Single Sugar Cone

$2.25

Double Sugar Cone

$3.25

Waffle Bowl

$3.50

Waffle Bowl 2 Scoop

$4.50

Single Cup

$2.25

Double Cup

$3.25

Rocky Road

A rich, dark chocolate ice cream generously sprinkled with chopped, roasted almonds and miniature marshmallows

Kids Cone

Single Cake Cone

$2.25

Double Cake Cone

$3.25

Single Sugar Cone

$2.25

Double Sugar Cone

$3.25

Waffle Bowl

$3.50

Waffle Bowl 2 Scoop

$4.50

Single Cup

$2.25

Double Cup

$3.25

Vanilla

Our most popular ice cream and with good reason. It's rich, homemade-tasting vanilla ice cream with a special hand-cranked flavor that's the best in the country.

Kids Cone

Single Cake Cone

$2.25

Double Cake Cone

$3.25

Single Sugar Cone

$2.25

Double Sugar Cone

$3.25

Waffle Bowl

$3.50

Waffle Bowl 2 Scoop

$4.50

Single Cup

$2.25

Double Cup

$3.25

Shakes/Malts

Shake

Hand-dipped shakes in any of our ice cream flavors.

$4.50

Flavor

Birthday Cake

Black Walnut

Chocolate Chip

Malt

Handmade Malts made from any of our ice cream flavors.

$4.50

Flavor

Birthday Cake

Black Walnut

Chocolate Chip

Floats

Coke and Vanilla Ice Cream

$4.50

Orange and Vanilla Ice Cream

$4.50

Root Beer and Vanilla Ice Cream

$4.50

Fudge

Amaretto Chocolate Swirl

Rich chocolate and amaretto fudge swirled together....Delish!

1-square (1/4 lb)

2-squares (1/2 lb)

3-squares (3/4 lb)

$12

4-squares (1 lb)

$16

Birthday Cake

Creamy vanilla fudge blended with colorful sprinkles. Happy Birthday!

1-square (1/4 lb)

2-squares (1/2 lb)

3-squares (3/4 lb)

$12

4-squares (1 lb)

$16

Butterfinger

Creamy vanilla fudge swirled with delicious Butterfinger bits and drizzled with chocolate.

1-square (1/4 lb)

2-squares (1/2 lb)

3-squares (3/4 lb)

$12

4-squares (1 lb)

$16

Cappuccino

A cup of yuuumm. Cappucino fudge sprinkled with cinnamon.

1-square (1/4 lb)

2-squares (1/2 lb)

3-squares (3/4 lb)

$12

4-squares (1 lb)

$16

Caramel Apple Pie

Creamy Caramel fudge swirled with real apple bits a a sprinkle of cinnamon.

1-square (1/4 lb)

2-squares (1/2 lb)

3-squares (3/4 lb)

$12

4-squares (1 lb)

$16

Classic Chocolate

Pure heaven. Classic rich creamy chocolate fudge.

1-square (1/4 lb)

2-squares (1/2 lb)

3-squares (3/4 lb)

$12

4-squares (1 lb)

$16

Chocolate Vanilla Swirl

Two classic flavors perfectly swirled together.

1-square (1/4 lb)

2-squares (1/2 lb)

3-squares (3/4 lb)

$12

4-squares (1 lb)

$16

Chocolate Walnut

Creamy chocolate fudge swirled with walnuts. Everyones favorite!

1-square (1/4 lb)

2-squares (1/2 lb)

3-squares (3/4 lb)

$12

4-squares (1 lb)

$16

Cookies and Cream

Anything better than cookies and milk? Cookies and Cream Fudge!

1-square (1/4 lb)

2-squares (1/2 lb)

3-squares (3/4 lb)

$12

4-squares (1 lb)

$16

Dark Chocolate Caramel Sea Salt

Dark Chocolate fudge with a layer of creamy caramel and sprinkled with sea salt.

1-square (1/4 lb)

2-squares (1/2 lb)

3-squares (3/4 lb)

$12

4-squares (1 lb)

$16

English Toffee

Creamy Vanilla fudge swirled with buttery English Toffee bits and drizzled with chocolate.

1-square (1/4 lb)

2-squares (1/2 lb)

3-squares (3/4 lb)

$12

4-squares (1 lb)

$16

Maple Walnut

Melt in your mouth Maple...chock full of walnuts. Amazing.

1-square (1/4 lb)

2-squares (1/2 lb)

3-squares (3/4 lb)

$12

4-squares (1 lb)

$16

Mint Chocolate Swirl

It doesn't get much better than this. Creamy chocolate and mint flavors swirled together beautifully.

1-square (1/4 lb)

2-squares (1/2 lb)

3-squares (3/4 lb)

$12

4-squares (1 lb)

$16

Orange Vanilla Swirl

Fresh flavors of orange and vanilla swirled together. Just like a "Dreamscicle".

1-square (1/4 lb)

2-squares (1/2 lb)

3-squares (3/4 lb)

$12

4-squares (1 lb)

$16

Peanut Butter

For the kid in all of us. Creamy peanut butter. Mmmmmmm

1-square (1/4 lb)

2-squares (1/2 lb)

3-squares (3/4 lb)

$12

4-squares (1 lb)

$16

Peanut Butter Chocolate

Two of the best flavors in the world. Chocolate fudge and peanut butter fudge layers...perfection!

1-square (1/4 lb)

2-squares (1/2 lb)

3-squares (3/4 lb)

$12

4-squares (1 lb)

$16

Raspberry Vanilla Swirl

Flavor explosion! Tastes just like fresh raspberries. SPECIAL ORDER...may take a few days longer to fill the order. Worth the wait.

1-square (1/4 lb)

2-squares (1/2 lb)

3-squares (3/4 lb)

$12

4-squares (1 lb)

$16

Root Beer

Tastes just like a root beer float.....maybe better!

1-square (1/4 lb)

2-squares (1/2 lb)

3-squares (3/4 lb)

$12

4-squares (1 lb)

$16

Salted Caramel

Creamy caramel and sea salt swirled throughout yummy vanilla fudge.

1-square (1/4 lb)

2-squares (1/2 lb)

3-squares (3/4 lb)

$12

4-squares (1 lb)

$16

Snickers

Rich Chocolate fudge with a layer of creamy caramel and salted peanuts. Tastes just like a "Snickers" candy bar.

1-square (1/4 lb)

2-squares (1/2 lb)

3-squares (3/4 lb)

$12

4-squares (1 lb)

$16

Vanilla

Pure creamy vanilla fudge that will melt in your mouth.

1-square (1/4 lb)

2-squares (1/2 lb)

3-squares (3/4 lb)

$12

4-squares (1 lb)

$16

Chocolates

Dark Chocolate Fudge Truffle

Whipped dark chocolate center, dipped in dark chocolate, drizzled with milk chocolate, and topped with course sea salt.

$3.95

Dark Chocolate Sea Salt Truffle

Whipped dark chocolate center, dipped in dark chocolate, drizzled with milk chocolate, and topped with course sea salt.

$3.95

Milk Mousse Truffle

Whipped milk mousse covered with rich milk chocolate

$3.95

Double Chocolate Truffle

$3.95

Red Velvet Truffle

$3.95

Triple Chocolate Truffle

Dark Chocolate covered in Milk Chocolate covered in White Chocolate

$3.95

Butter Toffee Truffle

Whipped butter truffle dipped in Milk Chocolate and toffee bits

$3.95

Milk Chocolate Caramel Squares

Oh My!!

$2.95

Dark Chocolate Cherry

Almost Decadent!

$2.95

Dark Chocolate Covered Ginger

Mmmmmm....

$3.95

Chocolate Coconut Haystacks

A favorite flavor combination.

$3.95

Milk Chocolate Covered Marshmallow

Marshmallow covered in milk chocolate...perfect!

$1.25

Mint Souffle Bar

Mint Bar has smooth chocolate mint coated in green mint.

$2.95

Mudslides

Marshmallow, Caramel, Walnuts all covered in Milk Chocolate!

$4.95

Milk Chocolate Covered Oreos

Everyone loves Oreos... and then dipped in milk chocolate...YES PLEASE!

$1.50

Giant Peanut Butter Cup

Two of the BEST flavors ever...and GIANT sized.

$4.95

Giant Peanut Cluster

A fav...but BIGGER.

$3.95

Chocolate Covered Turtles

Caramel, Pecans, Covered in Milk Chocolate. YUM!!

$3.95

Caramel Cashew

Creamy caramel with cashew with a dollup of milk chocolate

$3.95

Beverages

Coke

Can

$1.25

Mexican Glass

$2.25

16 oz plastic bottle

$2.25

Diet Coke

16 oz. plastic bottle

$2.25

Dr. Pepper

16 oz. plastic bottle

$2.25

Diet Dr. Pepper

16 oz. plastic bottle

$2.25

Root Beer A&W

Can

$1.25

Mexican Glass

$2.25

16 oz plastic bottle

$2.25

Polly Pop Pineapple

Glass bottle

Polly Pop Cream Soda

Glass bottle

Polly Pop Root Beer

Glass bottle

Polly Pop Strawberry

Glass bottle

Polly Pop Peach

Glass bottle

Polly Pop Grape

Glass bottle

Polly Pop Orange

Glass bottle

Coffee

Hot Chocolate

Water

$1.25